Page 2: Enchanted Forest review (Books 1 and 2)
Enchanted Forest Playlist:
- Anything classical; but also…
- “Not a Pretty Girl,” by Ani DiFranco
- “Dragon Lady,” by Blue Oyster Cult
- “Cat Duet,” by Rossini
- “Sarah,” by Trevor Jones (from the Labyrinth soundtrack)
Series rating so far: 5 out of 5 extremely useful buckets of soapy lemon water
Recommended if you like:
- Lovingly satirical world-building that presents fairy tale tropes as conscious fashions and traditions that not everyone is thrilled about (like the “Wicked Uncle” in Book 2…he’s really very sweet, but goshdarn it, he has a reputation to keep!)
- Anti-damsels who don’t mind cooking and cleaning, as long as they’re not doing it for some macho knight who gets to have all the adventures by himself.
- Tangible magic systems — I LOVE how magic is described as a web running through the Enchanted Forest, whose strings can be pulled and twisted to create spells and warp space.
- Totally nonchalant queer representation (there’s a dragon who’s described as too young to have decided their gender yet) and a pointed defiance of gender norms (“King” and “Queen” are job titles among the dragons, and each can be applied to any dragon of any gender).
Pitfalls/WARNING: Nothing strong enough to affect my rating, because it only affects the e-book, and it only applies to readers (like myself) who are experiencing the story in chronological order (as opposed to publishing order). Do NOT read the author’s intro to Searching for Dragons unless you want the ending spoiled. Wrede assumes (not illogically) that her readers have already read the series beginning with the fourth book, which she wrote first.
For new readers, it may be more fun to experience certain plot points as if they’re not inevitable. To put it vaguely, Cimorene could have made a very different choice at the end of Searching. Wrede could have gone a different route and it would’ve made just as much sense, and fit just as well with Cimorene’s character. On the other hand, the canon outcome does create some fun possibilities for defying more fairy tale tropes and flipping more gender norms. See me in the comments if you want to debate!
Mental movie cast: Maybe it was the mention of his dark hair being unusually messy, but I immediately decided that Mendanbar has to be played by Daniel Radcliffe in his Miracle Workers: Dark Ages wig. Dragon council’s still out on Cimorene, but it would have to be someone who can master that shrewd/annoyed/slightly smug look on the 1990 hardcover.
I must admit, my favorite part was reading this: 5 out of 5 extremely useful buckets of soapy lemon water. Have you finished all the books? It’s up there on my list as a favorite series of mine. I honestly didn’t think I’d ever find a new favorite, but I have and now I wonder what else is out there 😀
I’ve just read Dealing and Searching, so far, but the other two are on my list! I love that you guys get me so well that you just knew I’d fall for this series. It’s so feel-good and clever! Also, I’m wondering if all our world needs right now is a few good buckets of soapy lemon water? 😜
Ha! That would be awesome. I know just who to dump the water on, too.
You mean, who to Drumpf the water on? 😂
[…] also wasn’t thrilled about the ending. As I said re: the previous book, Cimorene’s arc could have gone in a totally different direction and, while the actual […]
[…] addition to the Toby connection, Rowell’s magic ‘verse is also a lot like Patricia Wrede’s Enchanted Forest in that it, too, has a plot-significant problem with dead zones (i.e. places where the magic has […]
[…] the main Toby series, I’ve also read most of her novellas and short stories; her Wayward Children series (review of Absent Dream here); and her Lumberjanes issue, “Somewhere That’s […]
[…] still maintain that Dealing With Dragons (reviewed here) is the best of Patricia C. Wrede’s Enchanted Forest quartet. Cimorene gets to be way more […]
[…] thinking, of course, of Patricia Wrede’s Dealing With Dragons (reviewed here) the hardcover edition of which I was delighted to find at Half-Price Books […]